Motivación en las sentencias emitidas por los jueces de primer nivel en Ecuador

Abstract

Abstract:.This thesis presents a critical legal analysis based on Judgment No. 06282-2020-00171, a first-instance judgment issued by the Criminal Judicial Unit located in the Riobamba Canton, Chimborazo Province. The analysis will be conducted from an academic perspective, contributing to professional development. It evaluates whether the judicial resolution complies with the motivational requirements established in the Constitution of the Republic of Ecuador, the Comprehensive Organic Criminal Code, and current jurisprudential standards. The study focuses on determining the argumentative sufficiency of the ruling, its logical coherence, and its correct application of the law to the case in question. As a result of the analysis, aspects were identified that allow for reflection on the quality of judicial decisions and their impact on effective judicial protection. This work represents an academic exercise, which is expected to contribute to the development of competencies. fundamental analytical and legal principles for the future professional practice in the field of law, without affecting the constitutional rights of those involved. The methodology used in this research is the analysis of the motivation of judgments, which stems from the analytical method that involves breaking down the judgment into its fundamental parts to analyze and evaluate the arguments.